While the market is red-hot, many prominent New York dealers are scrambling
for ever more gallery space. Some of them have traded up to bigger spaces that
allow them to show larger works, while others have opened second — or even
third — galleries.
The competition for gallery space is probably fiercest right at the heart
of the art market in Chelsea, the neighborhood that has become a magnet for
contemporary art collectors. The core gallery district stretches roughly from
20th to 26th Streets between 10th and 11th Avenues. There are a handful of
galleries a bit north or south, but almost everything is west of 10th Avenue.
“That’s where the hedge fund people go to drop a lot of cash,” said
Matthew Bergey, a real estate broker at CB Richard Ellis, who is an art
collector himself. “They enjoy art, and they are also trying to get into the
right social stratosphere,” by collecting contemporary art.
Mr. Bergey said the tight market for space in the Chelsea gallery district
is forcing out many young dealers. Some of them are taking space a few streets
farther south, toward the West Village, while others are opening galleries on
the Bowery, in the East Village. But when new space becomes available in
Chelsea, it is usually the better-established dealers who can snare it.
A decade ago, this small outpost on the far West Side of Manhattan
was mostly occupied by warehouses and parking garages. Then, there was a sea
change in SoHo, a nearby neighborhood that was filled with art galleries at
the time, but is now mostly dotted with luxury shops.
Back in the mid-1990s, when name retailers started paying annual rents of
more than $200 a square foot in SoHo, warehouses in Chelsea were renting for
$8 or $9 a square foot. The art dealers started moving to Chelsea in droves,
and landlords were soon able to charge more than $20 a square foot, said Alan
Weisman, a real estate broker at Grubb & Ellis.
The rent increases did not stop there. Mr. Weisman said a Chelsea warehouse
that fetched $8 a square foot in 1995 might rent for $80 a foot today. He said
that even above the ground floor, gallery space can rent for as much as $50 a
square foot now.
This has not suppressed demand. Storefront leases within these few square
blocks are so prized that some well-connected dealers have started taking two
or three of them.
For example, Paula Cooper already had two galleries, at 521 and 534 West
21st Street, when she stumbled upon her third space. Ms. Cooper, who lives in
the neighborhood, was passing a gallery and saw that the occupants were moving
out. She quickly sublet the space, “mostly because it was there,” said
Steve Henry, the director of the Paula Cooper Gallery. “It was a bit
serendipitous.”
Paula Cooper has just opened the first show in this new gallery at 465 West
23rd Street, just east of 10th Avenue.
To be sure, Chelsea is not the only art district in Manhattan. There has
long been a nexus for art dealers uptown on 57th Street near Fifth Avenue,
which is close to the Museum of Modern Art.
This is also, not incidentally, right on the doorstep of some of the
dealers’ best customers. Many hedge funds have offices nearby; and the Upper
East Side, where many of the city’s wealthiest residents live, is a short
walk away. But even many prominent dealers who are well established on 57th
Street feel the urge to open galleries in Chelsea.
Marlborough Gallery, a large dealer with galleries all over the world, has
had its New York headquarters on 57th Street just west of Fifth Avenue for
decades. Last year, it closed its old Chelsea outpost on 19th Street near
Seventh Avenue, in part because that was too far east of the Chelsea market,
said Tara K. Reddi, the vice president of Marlborough Gallery in New York.
Marlborough tried negotiating with the photographer Annie Leibovitz to
purchase a renovated garage that she owned on 26th Street between 10th and
11th Avenues. But after losing that bid, the gallery heard about a parking lot
one block south where a developer was planning to build a commercial
condominium building. “I always think that it is better to own,” Ms. Reddi
said.
Marlborough was one of the first galleries to buy a condominium in the
Chelsea Arts Tower, at 545 West 25th Street. All of units in this 20-story
building, which was completed in January, have been sold — most of them to
art galleries or fashion-design showrooms. Marlborough purchased the first two
floors. By getting in early, it was able to specify how it wanted the space
configured.
The gallery, which is to open in September, will have about 4,000 square
feet of indoor exhibition space and a 1,200-square-foot terrace on the second
floor, where smaller sculptures can be shown.
One block south, half a dozen dealers have rented storefronts in a new
16-story luxury residential condominium building. This building, at 555 West
23rd Street, runs through to 24th Street and has three galleries on each side.
Jeff Levine, the president of Douglaston Development, the building’s
developer, said he knew he would be renting these storefronts to galleries,
because “that block of 24th Street was wall-to-wall galleries.”
So, he said, the retail space was designed to suit the needs of galleries,
for example, by providing large windows and high-quality entrances. The
developer also invested in a top climate control system because “art is very
sensitive to temperature and humidity,” Mr. Levine said.
Mr. Rubenstein opened his third gallery on West 23rd and 24th Streets in
this building. Clearly, he is among this neighborhood’s true believers. He
said that by now, even far-flung artists have caught on to the mystique of
Chelsea.
“If you go to Berlin and tell an artist that you are only going to show
them on 57th Street and not in Chelsea, they won’t show with you,” Mr.
Rubenstein said.